LEEVLI
PRACTICAL GUIDE

RENTER RIGHTS

How to Evict a Housemate: Co-Tenants, Subtenants, Lodgers and Guests Each Follow Different Rules

From Listings to Living

Eight months into sharing a two-bedroom, your housemate has stopped paying their half, the friend who was "staying a week" is still on the couch, and you want both of them gone. You have the keys, your name is on the mailbox and you pay the internet bill. None of that, on its own, gives you the right to make anyone leave.

How to evict a housemate depends almost entirely on one question: who holds the lease or the title, and what is the other person's relationship to it? If you both signed the lease, you are co-tenants and generally only the landlord can evict either of you. If you hold the lease and the housemate pays rent to you, you are their landlord and must use notice and court like any other landlord. If you own the home and rent them a room, they may be a lodger, and some states give owners a shorter route. If they never paid rent, they may be a guest, removed under yet another set of rules.

One rule holds across all four: changing the locks, removing belongings or cutting off utilities is not a lawful shortcut, even between housemates.

Leevli Editorial Team

Roommate vs tenant eviction: what the two of you are to each other

Before you decide how to evict a housemate, place them in one of these categories. The labels you used when they moved in matter less than the facts: who signed what, and who pays whom.

Your housemate isWho can make them leaveUsual process
A co-tenant on the same leaseOnly the landlordLandlord's notice and eviction case, or a negotiated exit
Your subtenant (you hold the lease, they pay you)You, as their landlordWritten notice under state law, then an eviction case
A lodger renting a room in a home you own and live inYou, as ownerWritten notice; in California, a single lodger can be removed after notice without a full eviction case
A guest who never paid or agreed to pay rentThe person entitled to possessionVaries by state, from a court case to a law enforcement affidavit

The guest category is narrower than people assume. The D.C. Bar Pro Bono Center's FAQ on evicting guests, roommates and family members says a person is generally a tenant if they have paid or agreed to pay rent, which can include work or goods, and that "you cannot change a tenant into a guest just by changing what you call that person in your agreement." A verbal arrangement can create a tenancy, as our guide to lease vs. rent explains, so a housemate eviction without lease paperwork is still usually an eviction.

If you are both on the lease

Co-tenants stand on equal footing. San Francisco's Rent Board says plainly on its page about evictions of roommates and subtenants that only landlords can evict tenants and that co-tenants cannot evict each other. The D.C. FAQ says co-tenants who both signed the lease "usually cannot evict each other," even if one stops paying rent or breaks the lease.

That leaves three realistic paths:

  • A negotiated exit. Agree on a move-out date in writing, settle the security deposit split and decide who pays the remaining months.
  • A lease change with the landlord. Ask the landlord to release the departing housemate and, if you want, add a replacement. Our guide to the lease termination letter includes a mutual termination sample you can adapt for a partial release.
  • The landlord's own enforcement. If the housemate breaks the lease, the landlord has the right to act. Think before you ask: on a joint lease, a breach can put the whole tenancy at risk, not only the person who caused it.

Money is usually the real issue. If your lease makes each signer jointly and severally liable, the landlord can collect the full rent from you when your housemate stops paying; our guide to cosigner vs guarantor explains that liability and what happens to a cosigner when a roommate leaves. Our printable lease agreement guide explains why every adult who lives in the unit should sign.

How to evict a housemate when you are the master tenant

The housemate eviction process starts with the paperwork. If your name is on the lease and the housemate pays rent to you, you have a sublease, and you are their landlord. California's Department of Real Estate says in its California Tenants guide that with a sublease, the original lease stays in full force, the original tenant is still responsible for paying the landlord, and the original tenant "functions as a landlord to the subtenant." The guide also notes that many leases prohibit subletting without the landlord's consent, so check yours first: an unauthorized sublease can become a problem in your own tenancy.

Being the landlord means following landlord rules. You give the written notice your state requires, of the right length and served by a permitted method, and if the subtenant stays, you file an eviction case. San Francisco's Rent Board says master tenants "must comply with state law unlawful detainer procedures in order to evict a subtenant." For a subtenant with no written agreement, our guide to writing an eviction notice without a lease covers the notice periods, contents and service rules.

Local rent laws can add another layer. In San Francisco, the same Rent Board page says a master tenant who lives with a subtenant may evict without just cause, but for subtenancies that began on or after May 25, 1998, only if the master tenant told the subtenant in writing, before the tenancy began, that it is not subject to the ordinance's just cause provisions. A master tenant in the Mission District who skipped that notice may need a just cause to end the subtenancy. Other cities with rent control have their own versions, so check yours.

How to kick out a roommate not on lease when you own the home

An owner who lives in the home and rents out a room is in a different position, and California shows how much that can matter. Under California Civil Code 1946.5, a lodger is a person who contracts with the owner for a room, or room and board, in a dwelling the owner personally occupies, where the owner keeps access to all areas the lodger uses and has overall control of the home.

When there is only one lodger, either side can end the arrangement with written notice, served the way eviction notices are served or by certified or registered mail, restricted delivery, with return receipt. The statute ties the notice length to Civil Code 1946, which calls for notice at least as long as the rental period, up to 30 days; the DRE guide reads it as the same notice any periodic tenancy requires, so confirm the period before relying on the shorter one. Once the notice period expires, the lodger's right to stay "is terminated by operation of law," and removal can proceed under Penal Code 602.3; the DRE guide says the lodger may then be removed as a trespasser. It also adds two warnings: most lodgers have the same rights as tenants, and a lodger who disputes that status may force the owner to file an unlawful detainer case anyway. With two or more lodgers, section 1946.5 does not apply.

Owners renting out a room should also look at their own coverage, since a paying occupant is a change your insurer and lender may care about. Our guide to whether you have to have homeowners insurance covers what lenders and associations require.

Housemate eviction without lease when no rent was paid

A guest who never paid or agreed to pay rent is not a tenant, but states handle the removal very differently. Three examples:

Washington, D.C.: use the court

The D.C. FAQ calls the court process "the safest way to remove a guest," with a case filed in the Landlord and Tenant Branch of D.C. Superior Court, and says a 30-day notice to quit is usually not required for guests, with exceptions. It warns that locking a guest out carries risks, including wrongful eviction damages if the person turns out to be a tenant. Note that the FAQ was last updated in December 2019, so confirm current court procedures if you live in Washington, D.C.

Florida: the transient occupant affidavit

Florida Statutes 82.035 defines a transient occupant as a person whose stay has been brief, is not under a lease, and was intended to be transient. Factors include paying minimal or no rent, having no room of their own, having few belongings there and having an apparent permanent residence elsewhere. If the person stays after being told to leave, the party entitled to possession can give a law enforcement officer a sworn affidavit setting out those facts, and the officer may direct the person to leave. The statute also gives a wrongly removed person a claim for damages against whoever asked for the removal. A condo owner in Brickell whose cousin has stayed for two weeks may fit the definition; a housemate who has paid rent for a year does not.

New York: the licensee and the ten-day notice

New York's summary proceeding law, RPAPL 713, lets a person entitled to possession bring a case against a licensee whose license has expired or been revoked, after serving a ten-day notice to quit. So a guest in New York who qualifies as a licensee still has to be removed through a court proceeding, on a shorter notice than a tenant gets.

Serving notice to roommate: what the paper should say

Whichever category applies, put the request in writing, even when you also say it in person. A workable notice names the person, the address, the relationship (subtenant, lodger, guest), the date by which they must leave and the legal basis you rely on, with your signature and date. Deliver it by a method your state allows, keep a copy and write down when, how and to whom you gave it. If the housemate leaves on time, that paper is your record; if not, it is the first exhibit in your case. How long the court part takes from there is covered in how long eviction takes, and a filed case can follow the person into tenant screening, as when an eviction goes on your record explains.

No lockouts, even between housemates

A lockout can turn a housemate dispute into a lawsuit against the person who started it. The DRE guide says landlords may not lock out a tenant, cut off utilities or seize belongings to force a move, and that a landlord who does may owe actual damages plus penalties of up to $100 per day under California law. A master tenant evicting a subtenant is a landlord for these purposes. Even with a guest, the D.C. FAQ flags safety concerns, police involvement and wrongful eviction damages. Our renters rights guide covers the lockout penalties in other states.

A practical path that avoids court

A deal can be cheaper than court, and the math shows why. Say, as an illustration, that your housemate's share is $950 a month and four months remain on a joint lease. If they stop paying and you cannot replace them, you may be covering $3,800. Offering $500 toward their moving costs and a fast return of their share of the deposit, in exchange for a signed move-out date, can be cheaper than any court case.

  • Put the agreement in writing: move-out date, returning the keys, final rent, deposit split and what happens to anything left behind.
  • Bring the landlord in early if the lease needs to change, so the release is official.
  • Ask whether your city or county runs a community mediation program; a neutral third party can break a stalemate.
  • If the housemate is lining up a new place before your lease ends, our guide to renting an apartment while on another lease explains how new landlords view the overlap.

Domestic violence: a separate track

If the problem is abuse, an eviction is the wrong tool. In California, the courts' self-help guide on domestic violence restraining orders says an order can require the restrained person to move out of a home shared with the protected person, that there is no court fee to file, and that you do not need a lawyer. The protection is not limited to couples: California Family Code 6211 includes abuse against "a cohabitant or former cohabitant." The DRE guide adds that a tenant with a protective order excluding a co-tenant can ask the landlord in writing to change the locks; the landlord is not liable to the excluded co-tenant, who stays liable for the rent. Other states have their own protective order laws. If you are in danger, call 911.

For anything beyond a simple guest, a landlord tenant attorney or a legal aid office in your state can tell you which category your housemate falls into, and how to evict a housemate in that category, before you serve anything. And before you sign a shared lease next time, ask residents on Ask a Resident how the building handles roommate changes.

Questions to ask a current resident

Roommate problems are handled very differently from building to building, and residents know whether the landlord helps or makes it harder.

  • When a roommate moved out mid-lease, did the landlord agree to take them off the lease or add a replacement?
  • Did the landlord charge a fee to change the names on the lease?
  • Does management allow subletting a room, and did anyone have to ask permission in writing?
  • Has a roommate dispute here ever turned into an eviction case, and how long did it take?
  • How did the landlord split the security deposit when one roommate left early?
  • Did building staff get involved when a guest overstayed or a roommate changed the locks?
  • Does the landlord screen a replacement roommate the same way as a new tenant?

The short version

  • Who can evict a housemate depends on who holds the lease or title and whether the housemate pays rent.
  • Co-tenants on the same lease generally cannot evict each other; only the landlord can.
  • A master tenant is the subtenant's landlord and must use written notice and an eviction case.
  • California lets an owner remove a single lodger after proper written notice, but rules differ elsewhere.
  • Lockouts, removing belongings and cutting utilities are not lawful shortcuts, even with a guest.

How Leevli closes the information gap

Listings show the property, but they rarely explain the lived reality around it. On Leevli, a mover can explore the city, review neighborhood and building information, and ask a verified resident the specific questions that remain unanswered. That human layer helps readers know what to investigate before signing a lease, making an offer, or choosing between two addresses.

Frequently asked questions

You generally cannot. Co-tenants who signed the same lease have equal rights to the unit, and only the landlord can evict either of you. Your options are a negotiated move-out, a lease change that releases the housemate with the landlord's consent, or asking the landlord to enforce the lease, which can put your own tenancy at risk on a joint lease.

If they pay rent to you, they are likely your subtenant, and you must give the written notice your state requires and go to court if they stay. If they never paid or agreed to pay rent, they may be a guest, and removal depends on your state, from a court case in Washington, D.C. to a law enforcement affidavit for transient occupants in Florida.

The notice alone runs from days to months. A New York licensee gets a ten-day notice to quit, while a subtenant in a month-to-month arrangement usually gets the full notice period for a tenancy in your state, often 30 days or more. If the person stays, the court case adds weeks or longer. A negotiated move-out date can be the fastest route.

Notice costs little beyond copies and certified mail. Court filing fees, process servers and any attorney add more, and they vary by court and area. The bigger cost is often rent: on a joint lease, you may owe the full amount while the dispute drags on. In one illustrative case, covering a $950 share for four months came to $3,800.

Not to force them out. California's DRE guide says landlords who lock out a tenant can owe actual damages and penalties of up to $100 per day, and a master tenant is a landlord to a subtenant. Even with a guest, the D.C. Bar Pro Bono Center warns of wrongful eviction damages if the person turns out to be a tenant. A court order is the safe route.

A tenant eviction is a landlord removing a tenant through notice and court. A roommate situation depends on the relationship: a co-tenant cannot evict another co-tenant at all, a master tenant evicts a subtenant like any landlord, and an owner may have special rules for a lodger. The same court process often applies, but who has the right to start it changes.

Name the person and the address, describe the relationship (subtenant, lodger or guest), give the date by which they must leave and cite the legal basis, then sign and date it. Deliver it by a method your state allows, keep a copy and record when, how and to whom you gave it. For a subtenant without a written agreement, use your state's tenant notice rules.

Under Civil Code 1946.5, when an owner who lives in the home rents a room to a single lodger, either side can end the arrangement with written notice served by an approved method. When the notice period expires, the lodger's right to stay ends by operation of law, and removal can proceed under Penal Code 602.3. With two or more lodgers, the section does not apply.

Usually, yes. A verbal agreement to pay rent, even in work or goods, can create a tenancy, and the D.C. Bar Pro Bono Center says calling someone a guest does not change a tenant into one. If your housemate has been paying you rent, treat them as a tenant: written notice of the right length, proper service and a court case if they stay.

Taking matters into your own hands: packing their things, changing the locks or shutting off the internet and power to make them leave. These moves can turn you into the defendant. The second mistake is serving a notice without first working out whether the person is a co-tenant, subtenant, lodger or guest, because each category has its own rules.

Keep reading

Sources

This article is informational and does not constitute legal, financial, tax or insurance advice.